There’s an image doing the rounds on Twitter, wherein a girl, asked about “things my teacher can do better,” replies with “collective punishment.”
“It’s not fair,” she says, “on the many people who did nothing wrong.”
I get it. I do. I understand the unfairness; I also understand that for a certain type of pupil, the meek and the geek, it can be particularly difficult. Maybe they didn’t even know that the event occasioning the punishment happened; or maybe they did, and feel pressure from the more dominant members of a class to keep quiet, whether or not that pressure is articulated.
And yet I’m not convinced.
Yes, I know, I’m a monster, unfit to be responsible for the education of the young.
But is this always and everywhere the case? Really?
Let me give you a case study. It happens to be a true story of something which happened earlier this…
View original post 880 more words